For code/output blocks: Use ``` (aka backtick or grave accent) in a single line before and after the block. See:

Indicator development - missing a key piece

  • I'm still not sure when to use init and when to use next.

    The indicator I'm trying to build is simple.

    it's effectively: (i'm making up the actual formula, as this one is proprietary, but it's all regular variables off the data object)

    if the close > last close then x, if close < last close then y, if close == lastclose then 0

    effectively, what i want is:

    x = - *
    y = - *

    self.lines.myindicator = x if close > close(-1) else y if close < close(-1) else 0

    but that throws an error, and i'm really not sure where to start, there's so much about the indicators I don't really get at this point.

    bool should return bool, returned LineOwnOperation

    effectively - can I run boolean operations in init? if so, how? if not - then I guess I have to do this in next - but I run into trouble there too.

  • never mind, solved by using next

  • administrators

    @cemdev said in Indicator development - missing a key piece:

    x = - *
    y = - *
    self.lines.myindicator =  x if close > close(-1) else y if close < close(-1) else 0

    (Use ``` to quote code blocks)

    The above is almost ok for __init__. The problem being that not everything in python can be overridden and if ... elif ... else is one of those things. One needs to use backtrader.If (capital I to distinguish it even with from backtrader import *)

    See here: Docs - Platform Concepts, specifically the section Some non-overriden operators/functions

    With that in mind

    self.lines.myindicator =  bt.If(close > close(-1), x, bt.If(close < close(-1), y, 0))

    Which effectively says: if close > close(-1) then x elif close < close(-1) then y else 0

  • oh, that is EXCELLENT. Many thanks for the responses, especially on a sunday. i have it working with next, but i'll refactor with this, seems much cleaner.

Log in to reply

Looks like your connection to Backtrader Community was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.