3. Brain limitations: position sizing for forex
For code/output blocks: Use ``` (aka backtick or grave accent) in a single line before and after the block. See: http://commonmark.org/help/

Brain limitations: position sizing for forex

  • N

    This is tough, I think because the "size" has to be different if you want to convert 100% of the amount back to your base currency.

    So say my base currency is USD and I am trading USD/GBP (I know this isn't a real pair). If I convert $100 to £75, the order could look like this:

    self.buy_bracket(price=.75,limitprice=.78,stopprice=0.74)

    The sizer is called once, and lets say the idea is to always trade a size of $100, so we configured bt.sizers.FixedSizer,stake=100

    Now say the profit limit is hit, that means we will convert £100 into $133. But we only had £75 which means we will be taking some sort of a position instead of closing it out.

    I'm trying to figure out how we would size this properly, but it seems to be a limitation in my brain.

    0
  • B
    administrators

    Imho you approach the problem from the wrong side. You convert the price, but you want to convert the size

    self.buy_bracket(price=100, ...)

    The Sizer (a custom one) will then say that the maximum size is 75.

    The position will be closed with the right size because the take-profit and stop-loss sizes are the same as that from the main order.

    1
    N
     2 Replies
  • N

    @backtrader oh that's very interesting and makes perfect sense, thank you!

    0
  • N

    @backtrader Actually, I'm unable to see how to apply this.

    If we have

    self.buy_bracket(price=100,...)

    But the actual price is $.75, the order will go to the broker at $100... I'm very confused. Maybe the right thing to do is to manually create the bracket orders.

    0
  • B
    administrators

    See this other thread: Community - Backtesting oanda/forex

    1